Overall score
Clayton Bay
28.1/100
Hindmarsh Island
23.8/100
Clayton Bay vs Hindmarsh Island, SA suburb comparison
Hindmarsh Island for retirees and families.
See which suburb leads on livability, safety, schools, and lifestyle.
Head to head
Visual comparison
Clayton BayHindmarsh Island
Crime rate
Clayton Bay
23.8 / 1k
Hindmarsh Island
18.7 / 1k
Nearby amenities
Clayton Bay
0
Hindmarsh Island
0
Population
Clayton Bay
472
Hindmarsh Island
1,846
Metric leadClayton Bay 2Hindmarsh Island 33 tiedacross 8 compared metrics
Livability profile
Desirability pillars scored 0–100 vs comparable suburbs
Quick verdicts
Clearer edge on lifestyle fit (score gap ≥ 3)
- Best for retireesHindmarsh Island
- Best for familiesHindmarsh Island
Audience fit
Who each suburb suits — composite scores out of 100
All metrics
Side-by-side scores for every compared metric.
Full comparison table
Exact figures for every metric — winner highlighted in bold.
| Category | Clayton Bay | Hindmarsh Island |
|---|---|---|
| Overall score | 28.1/100 | 23.8/100 |
| Housing (desirability) | 2.6/100 | 2.6/100 |
| Crime rate | 23.8 / 1k | 18.7 / 1k |
| Walkability | 0.0/100 | 0.0/100 |
| Nearby amenities | 0 | 0 |
| Planning activity | 23 | 106 |
| Population | 472 | 1,846 |
| SEIFA (IRSAD decile) | 2/10 | 3/10 |
Comparison summary
Clayton Bay is a slower-paced smaller community with open surrounds, while Hindmarsh Island is a slower-paced smaller community with open surrounds.
Clayton Bay tends to lead on a quieter safety profile and overall desirability, while Hindmarsh Island stands out for a larger local community and stronger socioeconomic advantage.
Families and value-focused buyers may find Clayton Bay the better fit, while investors are more likely to prefer Hindmarsh Island.